on December 15, 2023 Austin Roofing Contractors

Can Landlords Make Tenants Pay for Roof Repair?

Subscribe to Email Updates

When tenants experience roof leaks, the first response is to call the landlord and request repairs; when properties have damaged or even older roofs, leaks can be common occurrences. Once a leak appears, tenants often face the option of either spending money out of their pocket for a quick repair or waiting for landlords or property owners to organize repairs - neither option is exactly encouraging.

Is My Landlord Responsible for a Roof Replacement or Repair?

The first step is to verify who is responsible for repairing or replacing the roof; this responsibility should be outlined in the lease agreement and should stipulate whether the landlord or the tenant must pay the cost of repairs. For example, if a licensed contractor causes major damage to your roof when trying to fix a leak, the lease should outline who is responsible for that. Typically, landlords would cover the cost when a contractor breaks something in or around the property.

The Lease Agreement

When renting a space, whether commercial or residential, you, as a tenant, will be asked to sign a lease or contract stipulating that you agree to rent a property owned by someone else. The leasing contract is the document where the responsibilities of the landlord and the renter are outlined and defined, including who is responsible for the cost of specific repairs.

The roof and its condition are essential to the quality of the property’s use. Generally, the property owner is responsible for necessary roof repairs or, eventually, roof replacements unless the tenant has caused the roof damage. 

When a roof leaks because of inclement weather, old age, missing shingles, or similar, the property owner is responsible for finding a roofing contractor and paying for any necessary repairs. Sometimes, a landlord may permit a tenant to provide several estimates for roof work; however, tenants should request permission from landlords to do so. Ultimately, the landlord has this responsibility.

In the case of the tenant causing the damage, the lease contract may contain a clause permitting a property owner to subtract the cost of necessary repairs from the tenant’s security deposit - or require the tenant to pay the expenses directly. It’s important to reread any leasing agreement you have signed as a tenant; ultimately, it is the leasing agreement that will determine who foots the bill.

The Cause of Roof Damage

Naturally, the cause of any roof damage is a determining factor in who pays for the repair costs. Landlords are usually responsible for roof repair or replacement when a natural disaster, such as an earthquake or a storm, causes damage. However, if the tenant does manage to damage the roof somehow, they may be required to pay the bill.

The landlord will typically specify these conditions in the lease agreement presented for signing; that is why tenants must read through a rental contract thoroughly before signing,  and clarify vague language or confusing clauses. Knowing your responsibilities as a tenant will facilitate navigating repair and replacement issues, including the roof.

Can My Landlord Make Me Pay for Roof Repairs?

Maybe. The rights of both tenants and landlords vary depending on the state in which the property is located, so there is no ‘one answer’ for every situation. Still, some general conditions may need to be met before a tenant is obligated to pay.

Most states will allow landlords to make tenants pay for some repairs. The state of Florida, for example, requires property owners to maintain properties and hence do any repairs necessary to comply with state and local housing, health, and building regulations and codes; compliance with codes allows tenants to withhold rent payments. Tenants are also required not to damage the property in any way, including damage caused by guests or visitors of the tenants. The property owner can recover damage costs if a tenant violates this law.

The state of Indiana also holds landlords legally responsible for property upkeep, including roof repairs that are due to no fault of the tenant. In Indiana, the tenant must pay only if they cause the damage.

Texas law requires a landlord to repair any conditions negatively affecting safety and physical health - this includes roof leaks. However, a property owner can refuse to make those repairs if the tenant is behind on rent payments or has created the damage in need of repair. Texas Security deposit law also states that security deposits can only be withheld in the case of ‘substantial’ damage caused by a tenant or their guests, regardless of whether the damage has been caused to the roof, windows, walls, or other.

A property owner can enforce that tenants pay for roof repairs by mutual agreement and/or stipulation of such in a lease agreement, or by invoking the law and going to court. Tenants cannot be required to pay for everyday wear and tear, however - it is a property owner’s responsibility to cover the financial costs of maintaining the property.

Generally, roof repair costs are only mandatory for renters if the tenant (or guest of the tenant) causes the damage, or if the lease contains a specific clause that requires repair payments.

Roof Replacement Payments

No single answer exists for every situation, whether it is a residential or commercial property rental; everything depends on the lease agreement and the cause of the damage. Review your lease agreement immediately and communicate any concerns or clarify any questions you may have to avoid potential disputes in the future. 

Are Tenants Liable for Commercial Property Roof Repairs?

When renting a commercial property, the lease must indicate who is responsible for making the roof repairs. In most cases, the landlord is responsible for roof repairs, although there may be a few instances when the tenant is responsible, such as when the rental lease states that the tenant is responsible for roof condition and upkeep. Landlords may also require tenants to pay for commercial property roof repairs if the tenant causes damage through misuse or negligence, such as not maintaining gutters free of debris. It’s always wise to keep all maintenance records to support the roof condition.

Final Thoughts

The responsibility for paying roof repairs in a residential or commercial lease depends on the type of damage, who caused the damage, and what provisions have been stipulated in the lease agreement. If you have any doubts as a landlord or tenant, it’s wise to consult a real estate attorney before signing a lease; if you have already signed a lease, consult an attorney in case of a repair or payment dispute.

Landlords, Are you in need of a roofing contractor you can trust?  Click here to get in touch with Longhorn Roofing Est. 1985 

Image credit: https://stock.adobe.com/contributor/208970954/kt-stock?load_type=author&prev_url=detail